5 stars
Was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed this book. I watched the Netflix adaptation when it first came out and found it interesting enough. Thus, I expected to feel similarly about the book. However, I was instantly pulled in and did not want to put this down.
There are various changes made in the Netflix version. One aspect I especially liked about the book was that it truly focuses on Enola instead of checking in with Sherlock and Mycroft. While her adventures follow a similar path in both versions, I was more interested in seeing what she was up to rather than her brothers trying to find her. The book is very much about Enola, not just her relationship to Sherlock.
Fasted passed, the book envelops the reader in the world of 1888 including the fashion, technology, and societal expectations, especially as they applied to women and girls. Enola’s genius really comes out as she narrates her journey and walks the reader through her thought processes. Very engaging and exciting. I instantly connected with the style of writing.
The one nitpicky thing I will mention is the portrayal of the Romani people. The book was originally published in 2006 and is set in 1888. At the time it was generally acceptable to use the g-word to refer the Roma. This book uses the term and makes reference to other characters’ beliefs that the Roma are dirty thieves. Enola herself seems very accepting of them, often referring to them simply as nomads. I think this inclusion warrants a conversation about the rejection of the derogatory term and negative stereotypes as we don’t see much to refute the general negativity in the story itself.
Overall, a fun story that blends historical fiction, mystery, and adventure. I enjoy Enola’s free spirit, intelligence, and ability to stay one step ahead of her brothers. Will definitely be reading the next book.